So... Logan is a Masktchi, Vicky and Bob are Tarakotchis, Pepsi is a Young Mametchi and Penny is a Nikatchi.
I think Pepsi would look the cutest.
By the way, you can look up what characters your tamas are by doing this:
Go to the Reference Section in tthe Library.
Your bar should look like this: TamaTalk > General > Library > Reference Section
Then click V2 Character Chart and you can see!! It shows all of them.
My tamas are these:
Plain pink V1: Daisy, girl, Oniontchi
Light pink with hearts V2: Dizzy, boy, Oniontchi
Pink with icecream cones V3: Mario, boy, Patapatatchi
Light pink with ribbons V3: Fizzy, boy, Hashitamatchi
Light green with flowers V3: Luigi, boy, Young Mimitchi
Yellow with hotpink stars Entama: Memetchi♥, girl, Memetchi
Cafe Brown Entama: Tami♥, girl, Memepetchi
Hope you're not jealous, it took me a long time to earn money for all my tamas (except the V1 and the icecream V3, my parents paid for those two
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Big grin :D :D"
)