My Sisters Keeper

[monkeez_cutiez]

i don't know, but in the book Anna dies in a car accident and her kidneys are given to Kate and in the movie Kate dies of leukaemia and Anna is medically emancipated. I know it sounds confusing, I'm confusing myself here. grrr

 

[x.Roller-//-Coasters.x]

Yes, whoever changed the ending will regret it. The book was muuuuuuuch better. You can't change the person who dies. It's not right.

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

I personally prefer the movie

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

As you can see, I am obsessed with my sister's keeper. I added sofia vassilieva on facebook!

 

[always&f o r e v e r]

It looks creepy. And sad. I don't want to see it\:

 

[+[ b r u t a l ]+]

Aww.

You guys are making me want to see it. (':

But I dunno if I can stand it.

I can handle a little blood and gore but if there's vomiting in it too, I'll pass.

Those kinds of movies make me lose my appetite and they make me really sad.

 

[SimTama]

I've only seen the movie but I wanna read the book now and see which one's better

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

Are you serious ST? I thought you hated (well not hated but not a fan) reading. I can lend you the book when I get it back off of Haylee.

 

[SimTama]

I don't mind reading. It just depends on what book it is, and thanks

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

No probs

 

[Cinderpelt]

The movie is NOTHING compared to the book.

The book is one of my favorite reads ever <3

The movie was just alright.

 

[Mazeay]

i think the directing was great. the way Sofia spoke was great.
There was one particular line towards the end which made me cry. It was where Kate gives Sara the scrapbook. It goes like this

SARA: What is it?

KATE: ...It's everything.

That made me cry so much. that particular line was just so moving and i have no idea why. I obviously cried during this.

ANNA (off camera): My sister died that night. She just stopped breathing.

Soooooo sad.

Another one of the saddest parts in the movie for me, is when Sara is in Kate's hospital room, and she finally realizes that Kate wants to die. And they hug each other, and cry, and Kate dies that night. :/

And also the scene where Anna and Kate are outside on the picnik blanket, near the end, the day before Kate dies, and Anna is like "Will you wait for me?" but just the whole scene made my really, really sad.

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

yeah i totally bawled during those scenes. I reckon the book was good, but i realy liked the movie. i dont know why everyone says the movie was bad compared to the book. I liked the movie cuz you could see what the characters looked like and all that. but the book was good too.

 

[SimTama]

The book is good because of all the extra bits but I like the changes that they have made with the movie.

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

How far through it are you? It only took me about 4 days to read. But I read like books are suddenly gonna go out of fashion so yeh.

 

[SimTama]

I'm halfway through it at the moment.

 

[monkeez_cutiez]

I loved the movie the best. But as i have said thousands of times, the book was good too. but lots of swearing. lots. excessive almost.

 

[It`s Teri]

I just watched it last night. I want to read the book now. I think it's a good but sad movie. It's definitely one I want to see again.