ID L vs P's

[aquaedge]

I need some help, I've been all over this site and elsewhere trying to decide what to do.

I own an ID L and I love it so much that I wanted to buy another. More specifically the Princess Spacey version. When I was looking for that I stumbled across the P's. Sooo now I'm stuck.

I have seen the general differences. All the accessories and characters. One of the most important questions I want to ask for those who own a P is does it require a lot of your time? With the jobs and all do you need to constantly watch it? I've never played the v4 or 4.5 so I have no idea what to compare it to.

For those who have both, what would you recommend? Are P's generally the same as an ID L?

Thanks in advance!

 

[KuroiNeko-Chan]

You don't have to supervise you tama at school/work on a P's. You can buy Pierces for the P's to add on to it. The Princess Spacy iD L has more features built in than the P's. You can get an infra red phone or USB dongle to download extras to an iD L.

In my experience, an iD L is easier to care for than a P's.

In the end, it's your choice, but I would reccomend the iD L because it has more features built in.

 

[ichiro.malfoy]

In the end, it's your choice, but I would reccomend the iD L because it has more features built in.

I actually think that the P's has much more features...

 

[Brittygotchi]

P's are generally the same as the iD L, but some major differences that I notice the most are

-P's has Daycare/School/Work

-P's has more room for mistake when counting care misses

-P's Happy Meter fills much faster

-iD L has a ton more download games

-The P's has pierces (duh)

-When you connect 2 iD L's, your characters can take a photo and save it to an album (you can't do that when connecting it to a P's)

-The P's are much girlier

 

[Eternal Mametchi Fan]

iD L has characters I am more familiar with and better locations in my opinion. You can also grow plants, which you cannot do on the P's, and the iD L has more Tama Pets to adopt.

P's does have more features but it isn't neccessarily better; it depends on what kind of Tamagotchi you're after!

I love my Princess Spacy iD L better than both my P's and iD L. It's super-duper girly but it has Himespetchi, my favorite female character ever, and the games are really good!

 

[Jhud]

I'd say both versions have about the same amount of features, just different ones. Because let's be honest, P's still replaced some things from the iD L. I personally love the seeds, and there are none on the P's- you can get a tree though.

 

[SaitoHitomi]

I have both and I must say I prefer the P's. The P's is more detailed by way of graphics, when going out to the town I find the background on the ID L too cluttered for my taste but on the P's it's toned down. I like the look of the destinations better on the P's as well. I love the school and work feature, it really helps to have them work while I work and be rewarded with gp. I know on the p's you can't get as many pets or plant things but I'm not really missing the plants and the 5 pets you can get in my opinion are just enough. The p's also has a personality which is really awesome as well. And you can still get Himespetchi on the P's if you like that character.