This Is Halloween

[Jinx3295]

Of course we all know this is from the 1993 film 'Nightmare Before Christmas'

The opening song.

But there are three versions.

~ The Original

~ Marilyn Manson's

~ Panic At The Disco's

Which one do you like the best?

I like the original/Manson's.

Manson did a good job at capturing the darkness of the peice.

But what's your fave?

links:

orginal- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xpvdAJYvofI

Manson's -

//www.tamatalk.com/IB/applications/core/interface/js/spacer.png
PATD - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQcIC3SRBT4

 

[ZOOMrocks]

The original is good, as most originals usually are, Marilyn Manson just plain scares me no matter what he sings, but Panic!'s was good. 8D

EDIT: Okay, I should reword that. The original was great, as they should be, Marilyn Manson did a really great job at capturing the fear that the song needs, and even though it was the worst, Panic! was good. Even though they took out the fear.

 

[Notes.]

I liked Manson's best. I've actually been listening to his version of the song a lot, lately..

I really liked how he brought in guitar.

The original was good, and I thought Panic's version was quieter than what I would have expected, but I agree that Marilyn Manson really did do the best with how it was supposed to be creepy.

 

[x.Nobody]

Well... XD

 

 

The Original captured the Real eeriness and childlike fright that was intended for the song.

 

Manson's really got the 'essence' of scariness and brought it full-on. I really loved that one <3

 

Panic!'s... Got both. And I love Panic!. And Brendon-Ryan-Jon-Spencer <3

 

 

But for me, in all fairness, I guess it's a tie between Panic! and Manson. I loved them both x3

 

[Temari Nara]

I love Panic!'s

-Temari Nara

 

[Self:.:Pity]

X^D I made this topic, long time ago

I think Marilyn Manson is the best, as it fits in with his type of music as well. But I do so love the original.

And Manson ~

Panics was pathetic. They killed the song, they took the fear out of it and replaced with with a droll.

 

[tamagotchi_pal]

The original~

 

As much as I love P!ATD, their's would have to be second best.

 

[Jinx3295]

X^D I made this topic, long time agoI think Marilyn Manson is the best, as it fits in with his type of music as well. But I do so love the original.

And Manson ~

Panics was pathetic. They killed the song, they took the fear out of it and replaced with with a droll.

lol yeah, that's why i made it.

i got reminded by watching this vid with all three versions of the songs..

so i felt like bringing this back ^____^

hahahaha.

my god, panic is winning

wooow.

 

[Pink Craze]

The original~ 

As much as I love P!ATD, their's would have to be second best.

Really?

The original one was just amazing. I just simply love that one. =D

The Manson one was pretty good too. I remember first listening to it in the middle of the night. God, I got freaked out. But then, I don't think theend is as scary as the beginning of the song. It kind of lost it's touch by the end and I was like "Meh..."

The Panic one, as much as I like them, was AWFUL compared to the other two. It was all quiet. I can sit there, listen to it, and just be bored.

I love the original one. Love it.

 

[tamagotchi_pal]

Really?
The original one was just amazing. I just simply love that one. =D

The Manson one was pretty good too. I remember first listening to it in the middle of the night. God, I got freaked out. But then, I don't think theend is as scary as the beginning of the song. It kind of lost it's touch by the end and I was like "Meh..."

The Panic one, as much as I like them, was AWFUL compared to the other two. It was all quiet. I can sit there, listen to it, and just be bored.

I love the original one. Love it.

I love the origanal one too~

 

[paper*cut]

Marilyn's Version is best<3

 

[Self:.:Pity]

lol yeah, that's why i made it.i got reminded by watching this vid with all three versions of the songs..

so i felt like bringing this back ^____^

hahahaha.

my god, panic is winning

wooow.

Ita all those people who either hate Manson or love Panic ! to much to admit they did horrial here.

And then their cowards to say it.

 

[tamagotchi_pal]

Actually that doesnt mean they're cowards.

 

It's a matter of personal opinion.

 

[inSANE]

The order of my favorites would be

1. Manson's verson

2.PATD

3.Original

I really liked Manson's because they managed to capture the essence. I don't really like Marlyin Manson but I like this version. Then I like Panic's because Brendon's voice sounds nice. I didn't like the original version much because the singers were kinda annoying.

Dude...that looks kinda like the explanatory essays that I did in the 8th grade.

 

[Pink Craze]

Ita all those people who either hate Manson or love Panic ! to much to admit they did horrial here.
And then their cowards to say it.

I'll give you this: I personally think the Panic one was terrible. xP

 

[Self:.:Pity]

Actually that doesnt mean they're cowards. 

It's a matter of personal opinion.

But then, look at the amount of people who voted for Panic and then look at the amount of people who posted why the liked/disliked any other the verisons, on either side.

Somtimes it means they just dont want to, but other times not so much.

good for you, Diva ~

 

[Broken~Wings]

Original. Mason scares the poop outta me and P!ATD is okay but it doesn't capture the eerieness.

I just grew up to this point on the original and it's hard to hear it any other way and actually like it.

 

[wildcat_gal_101]

Diva: Same, but it's the only version I've heard so I voted for Panic's. xD

 

[x.Nobody]

Panic!/Manson's > Original

 

♥

 

[Becca Juice]

Manson's.

Duhhh.

Marilyn Manson owns the world<3

And I must say that Panic!'s version was terrible.

x_x