Renesmee or Leah?

[Tama_Mama27]

Hello! This thread is for people who have read Breaking Dawn and have liked it. For people who want to criticise the book, your opinion is valued but is not useful in this case.

Stephenie Meyer said she might write another book in the Twilight series sometime in the future (not near future unfortuantly). She said the book will be from Renesmee's point of view or Leah's point of view. Who do you think she should make her main character if she does decide to write the book?

My opinion: Renesmee! I think Stephenie should just stick to the main family. One reason would be I would definelty miss them. Also, I couldn't wait to get out of Jacob's point of view while reading Breaking Dawn. Another thing is that if she wrote a book about Leah, I think personally that not a lot of people would even bother to read it. I never liked Leah because she always rubbed off as a mean person and she definetly let that show in Breaking Dawn. It would probably be about how she was in love with Sam and then he broke her heart for Emily. It would definetly be...different...but not something I would be interested in. What do you guys think?

 

[MusicIsTehBomb]

I vote Leah. I loved Jacob's point of view. And reading about Renesmee's point of view would get easily boring. She was hardly in the story. What could you write about her life? Leah seems like she'd be more interesting- deeper, if you catch my drift. I'm a werewolf fan as well. And reading about what it would be like to be the only female werewolf would be more interesting than reading about a baby calling for her Mom.

 

[Becca Juice]

Gah.

Renesmee.

>_>

I hated having to hear about Jacob and the pack life all the time, it bored me.

I wanted my vampires back.

And Renesmee is one of my favorite characters =P

 

[Tama_Mama27]

I agree with Becca Juice, although MusicIsTehBomb does make a good point. I think if Stephenie Meyer starts off seven years later when Renesmee is fully grown, it would be more interesting. Also it could be a romance with Jacob and the werewolves would still play a big part in that aspect of the story. Thanks for your comments!

 

[hanatchi99]

I'd say Leah. Definetely. Because, well, I'm a werewolf person I've had enough of Stephenie's vamps, and it would be more interesting, to see it written from the point of view from the only lady wolf. And, I don't like Renesmee. Like, a perfect baby? *Snort*

 

[Pink Craze]

I agree with Becca.

I don't like Leah. I don't like the werewolfs. Shapeshifters, whatever you wish to call them.

I couldn't wait to finish reading Jacob's part in Breaking Dawn. If she wants to write more, she should stick to the vampire family.

 

[princess08]

I think Stephanie Meyer should stop at Breaking Dawn, honestly. x_x; But if she's writing from a point of view, and she has to, I pick...Aro.

Mind the invisible answers, m'dear.;3

 

[twilightfan232]

ugh NOT leah. I hated Jacobs point of view. I couldn't care less how their tribe came to be. I found myself skipping over a lot of the talking Jacob and his tribe did so if she did write one from Leahs i would not read it.

 

[x Rain x Hazard x]

Not Leah. I couldn't stand Jacob.

Definately Renesmee.

 

[Howl Into The Night]

Leah.

Bella+Edward kid=The Apocalypse.

 

[tama_genius]

Renesmee.

I like Leah but i just think Nessie's life would be more interesting.

 

[ToastyWarmSocks]

I think Stephanie Meyer should stop at Breaking Dawn, honestly. x_x; But if she's writing from a point of view, and she has to, I pick...Aro.
Mind the invisible answers, m'dear.;3

Ah, Aro. Yes. Or Caius. Even Marcus would be interesting. I wonder what the Volturi do, other then screw around with the Cullen family. :3